Retraction from The Economist

(retraction published 5/20/04 at

Clueless in St James's .......Last week we published a list that purported to show the IQ s of states voting for George Bush and Al Gore in 2000. Alas, we were the victim of a hoax: no such data exists. By way of apology, here are two very crude ratings of states' intelligence-and how they voted. (Two charts shown for states (1)Math scores for 14/15yo (2) %holding a Bachelor's degree or above)


St. Pete Times - Spreading The Economist's hoax

The same day the above retraction was made, a major Florida newspaper was spreading the false story The Economist had printed in it's May 15, 2004 issue:

Does IQ matter in politics?

A St Petersburg Times Editorial
Published May 20, 2004

"So Democrats really are smarter," teased the small headline in the latest issue of the Economist, a London-based news magazine that closely follows U.S. politics. That piqued our curiosity, so we read on. The magazine, using as its source IQ and the Wealth of Nations by Richard Lynn and Tatu Vanhanen, found that Al Gore carried nine of the 10 states with the highest average IQ in the 2000 presidential election, while George W. Bush swept the 10 states at the bottom of the list. We're not sure what this means, if anything, but Democrats may find some consolation in the fact that Gore won not only more popular votes than Bush but also more smart votes.

Gore won Connecticut (113), Massachusetts (111), New Jersey (111), New York (109), Rhode Island (107), Hawaii (106), Maryland (105), Illinois (104) and Delaware (103).

Bush carried only one of the high-IQ states - New Hampshire (105). However, he blew Gore away in the 10 states with the lowest average IQ - Alabama (90), Louisiana (90), Montana (90), Oklahoma (90), South Dakota (90), South Carolina (89), Wyoming (89), Idaho (87), Utah (87) and Mississippi (85).

We assume Florida was somewhere in the middle since it was not mentioned. However, we can't help but wonder why the average IQ of U.S. Supreme Court justices didn't make the list.


Go to: Non-Hoax data on State IQ's, based on SAT and ACT scores

Go to: 2004 Red-Blue state election chart with IQ's

Go to: Basic facts on IQ

Go to: Home page

Comments to: